Meeting Overview

MINUTES

HISTORIC  AREAS BOARD OF REVIEW JULY 8, 2014

 

MEMBERS PRESENT:         Scott Wheatley Wayne Garrison Thano Schoppe} Margaret Raso William Walther Joseph Chabot Larry Bucciarelli

 

ABSENT:                              None

 

 

 

 

ALSO PRESENT:                 Deborah Arbolino, Denise Sullivan,

Ann Marie Ambrose,

Administrative Aide Deputy Town Attorney Official Stenographer

 

 

Margaret Raso, Chairperson, called the meeting to order at 7:30 p.m. Hearings on this meeting’s agenda, which are made a part of this meeting, were held as noted below:

 

APPLICANTS       JOSEPH NAPOLI	DECISION       POOL&FENCE	HABR#       HABR#14-08
77.11I1I14;  R-15 zone	APPROVED
SCULLY 80.06 I 1  I 29; R-80 zone	PORCH AND ROOF APPROVED	HABR#14-09
HYUN 78.18 I 2 I 13.1; R-40 zone	POOL, FENCE, PATIO APPROVED	HABR#14-10

 

 

OTHER BUSINESS:

 

MORRIE BROWN for an amendment to HABR#14-06; 80.06 I 1   I 25; R-80 zoning district for an amendment to the previously approved pool cabana.

In order to save a 150 year old tree, the proposed pool cabana had to be reduced in size. When the reduction was made there were minor changes to the structure and the proposed pergola was removed.

Larry Bucciarelli made a motion to APPROVE the changes to the cabana, which motion was seconded by William Walter and carried unanimously.

 

 

3 DI.:! .:W    S)~  ~l 31  D  Nh\01

!8    1   lJd    12  inr hIOZ

 

N h\ 013 D I’! V i.i 0  ;J 0  Nf.\ 0 l

 

Page 2

HABR   Minutes

 

 

 

 

 

 

THE DECISIONS  RELATED  TO THE ABOVE  HEARINGS  are inserted  herein  and made part of these minutes.

 

There being  no further business  to come before  the Board,   on motion  duly made, seconded  and carried,   the meeting  was adjourned  at  9:15   P.M.

 

DATED:   July 8,  2014

 

 

 

 

DISTRIBUTION: APPLICANT

TOWN  ATTORNEY

DEPUTY    TOWN ATTORNEY

BUILDING INSPECTOR    (Individual   Decisions) TOWN BOARD   MEMBERS          SUPERVISOR

 

HISTOR~IAREAS  BOA:U_~W ~

BY:       ~Q~                                –

De  orah Arbolino

Administrative    Aide

 

 

301.:L:iO    S”.J310      ·H.,\Ql

 

28    T   lJd     12   1nr   hIOZ

 

Nl,\OlJONVlJO   _jQ r-:f.\01

 

APPROVED    AS PRESENTED TO:  Joseph Napoli

179 Kings Highway

Tappan,  New York  10983

DECISION

 

 

 

 

HABR#   14-08

July 8, 2014

 

 

 

 

FROM:  HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD  OF REVIEW,  TOWN  OF ORANGETOWN

 

 

 

HABR#l  4-08: Application  of  Joseph  Napoli  for review  of an above ground pool and fence at an existing  single-family  residence.  The premises  are located  at 179 Kings Highway,  in the Town of Orangetown,  Hamlet  of  Tappan,  New York.  Chapter  12, Section  12-4(A), Historic  Areas  Board  of Review.

Tax Numbers:  77.11I1I14;    R-15 zoning  district.

 

 

Heard by the HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD  OF REVIEW  at a meeting  held on Tuesday, July 8, 2014 at which time the Board made the following  determination:

 

Wayne  Garrison  recused  himself. Joseph Napoli  appeared.

The following  documents  were presented:

 

 

1. Site plan with the proposed  pool drawn  in.
2. Round pool installation  instructions  and pool safety ladder.
3. Brochure  picture  of the Cedar Tongue  and Groove  without  square lattice fence.

 

 

Joseph Napoli  stated that he would  like to install  a 15′ round pool in the rear yard of his house; that he would also like to install  a six-foot  cedar fence in the rear yard; that the filter would be placed by the lilac bushes  that cannot be seen from the street; that they are not proposing  to build  a deck around the pool and would be using the ladder to get in and out of the pool; and that they are not proposing  any additional  outdoor  lighting.

 

 

 

PUBLIC  COMMENT: No public  comment.

 

 

3 81.:! .:J O   S \!  \! 318  N /A 0 l

zc  1   LJd    12   1nr h102

 

 

FINDINGS   OF FACT:

 

The Board,  after personal  observation  of the property,  hearing  all the testimony  and reviewing  same, found  as fact, that: The application  as presented,  would not adversely  affect the Historic  District  and the surrounding  area. The design  and

materials  for the proposed    15′ round  cream/white  above ground pool and the six-foot

cedar tongue  and groove  fence with square  lattice  are complimentary  to the District.

 

 

1. The  15′ round  cream/white  above ground  pool with an outside  safety ladder shall be installed  in the rear of the house.
2. The fence shall be a six-foot  cedar tongue  and groove fence with square lattice

installed  inside the existing  chain-link  fence.

3. The mechanicals  for the pool shall be installed  within the circle of existing  lilac bushes.

 

 

 

 

THIS  APPROVAL/DECISION,       AND  ANY  MODIFICATIONS      OR  CONDITIONS SET  FORTH   HEREIN,   IS GRANTED   BY THE  HISTORICAL     AREA  BOARD  OF REVIEW    AND  IS  LIMITED    TO  THE   SPECIFIC     RELIEF    REQUESTED     AND SUBJECT         TO  THE  CONDITIONS    OR  MODIFICATIONS,      IF ANY,  SET  FORTH HEREIN.

 

** PRE-1918   CONSTRUCTION:   PLEASE   BE  ADVISED:   IN   THE  HISTORIC AREA,   ALL   CONSTRUCTION   REQUIRING   A  BUILDING   PERMIT   OR  ANY EXTERIOR      CHANGES     (INCLUDING     PAINT     COLOR)    TO    BUILDINGS CONSTRUCTED    PRIOR    TO   1918,   REQUIRES     APPROVAL    FROM    THE HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD OF REVIEW.

 

PRIOR APPROVAL OF THE HISTORICAL  AREA BOARD OF REVIEW IS REQUIRED  PRIOR TO ANY CHANGE OR MODIFICATION  OF THE REQUIREMENTS   AND/OR  CONDITIONS   SET  FORTH  IN THIS  DECISION, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED  TO:

 

 

3 81.:l :10  S ~ ~! 31 o  N l.\ 0 l

 

2~   i:   Wd   12  1nr  hIOZ

 

 

• ROOFING SHINGLES (IF CHANGING  COLOR)

o  SIDING

o DECORATIVE  SIDING

o SOFFITS  & FASCIA

o GUTTERS  AND LEADERS

oWINDOWS

• TRIM eSHUTTERS o DOORS

o LIGHTING

• LOCATION OF AIR CONDITIONING  UNITS

o  WALKWAYS, PATIOS

o  POOLS, SPAS AND FENCES

• SIGNS
• ANY CHANGE   IN  THE  ABOVE  LIST   INCLUDING   COLOR,    MATERIAL   AND/OR MANUFACTURER

 

IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS,  PLEASE  CONTACT  DEBBIE  ARBO LINO, CLERK TO THE HISTORIC  AREA BOARD OF REVIEW AT (845)  359-8410.

 

 

 

 

DECISION:    In view  of the foregoing  and the testimony  before  the Board,   the application for the above ground pool,   and cedar fence is APPROVED.

 

 

The foregoing  resolution  was presented  and moved  by Thano  Schoppe!,   seconded  by William   Walther;    and carried   as follows:   Margaret  Raso,   aye; Larry Bucciarelli,    aye; William  Walther,   aye;   Scott Wheatley,  aye Thano  Schoppel,   aye;  and  Joseph  Chabot, aye.  Wayne  Garrison  recused  himself.

 

The Administrative    Aide  to  the Board  is  hereby  authorized,   directed  and empowered  to sign  this  decision    and file  a certified  copy thereof  in the office  of the Town Clerk.

 

Dated:   July 8, 2014

 

 

HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD  OF REVIEW TOWN  OF ORANGETOWN

 

 

 

BY~1~

 

 

DISTRIBUTION:

 

APPLICANT

TOWN BOARD MEMBERS HABR MEMBERS SUPERVISOR

TOWN ATTORNEY

DEPUTY TOWN ATTORNEY OBZPAE

BUILDING   INSPECTOR- R.A.0.

TOWN CLERK

HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT TOWN HISTORIAN

DEPT. OF ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING

HABR,  1’13,   f’ILE

PB, ZBA, ACABOR CHAIRMAN

 

 

 

 

3 81:! .:l 0 s ) ! \ !    31 0 [\Ji,\ 0 l

 

Z8    T   LJd   12   lilr  hl02

 

APPROVED   AS PRESENTED TO:  Walter  Aurell  (Scully)

171 Kings Highway

Orangeburg,  New York  10962

DECISION

 

 

 

 

HABR#   14-09

July 8, 2014

 

 

FROM:  HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD  OF REVIEW,  TOWN  OF ORANGETOWN

 

 

 

HABR#14-09:   Application  of  Sean Scully for review  of a roof at an existing  single• family residence.  The premises  are located  at 19 Ludlow  Lane, in the Town of Orangetown,  Hamlet  of  Palisades,  New York.  Chapter  12, Section  12-4(A), Historic Areas  Board of Review.

Tax Numbers:  80.06 I 1  I 29; R-80 zoning district.

 

 

Heard by the HISTORIC AREAS BOARD OF REVIEW at a meeting held on Tuesday, July 8, 2014 at which time the Board made the following determination:

 

 

 

Walter Aurell, Architect, appeared.

 

The following documents were presented:

 

1. Site plan.
2. Architectural plans labeled “New Roof & Existing Condition” (4 pages).

 

 

 

 

Walter Aurell, Architect, stated that the applicant would like to add a section of roof to the existing porch; that the deck of the porch exists and this section of the porch does not have a roof; that they are proposing to add a column and fill in the roof in that area; that the roof material for the porch section of the house would be Sheffield Metals in slate grey; that the house roof needs to be replaced and they are proposing to replace that roof with a synthetic slate material that has a chipped edge to it in DaVinci Slate Black; that the there are no plans presently to paint the house; and that he will relay to the applicant

the concerns of the Board regarding the color of the roof with the yellow mustard color of the house.

 

 

 

 

PUBLIC COMMENT: No public comment.

 

 

so..; u.:i :..:’0

‘:)’\1.  \1· -•il.”:i     -J

\I J/’;0\   -I

 

 

2c   1  Wd   12  1nr  hlD2

 

Nfl\013 o Ni/’d 0  .:’. 0  N i.\Ol

 

Scully

HABR#  14-09

Page 2 of  3

 

 

FINDINGS   OF  FACT:

 

 

The Board,  after personal  observation  of the property,  hearing  all the testimony  and reviewing  same, found  as fact, that: The application  as presented, would not adversely affect the Historic District and the surrounding area. The design and materials for the proposed house roof and porch roof  are complimentary to the District.

 

1. The roof of the porch shall be filled in to cover the existing decking and a new column added to accommodate the new slate grey metal roof for the porch.
2. The new house roof shall be synthetic slate with a chipped edge in DaVinci Slate black.
3. The gutters and leaders shall be white to match the existing.
4. The trim shall be white to match the exiting.

 

 

 

THIS APPROVAL/DECISION,   AND ANY MODIFICATIONS   OR CONDITIONS SET FORTH  HEREIN,  IS GRANTED BY THE HISTORICAL  AREA BOARD OF REVIEW  AND IS LIMITED   TO  THE  SPECIFIC   RELIEF REQUESTED  AND SUBJECT  TO THE CONDITIONS  OR MODIFICATIONS,  IF ANY, SET FORTH HEREIN.

 

** PRE-1918   CONSTRUCTION:   PLEASE   BE  ADVISED:   IN   THE  HISTORIC AREA,   ALL   CONSTRUCTION   REQUIRING   A  BUILDING   PERMIT   OR  ANY EXTERIOR      CHANGES     (INCLUDING     PAINT     COLOR)    TO    BUILDINGS CONSTRUCTED    PRIOR    TO   1918,   REQUIRES     APPROVAL    FROM    THE HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD OF REVIEW.

 

PRIOR APPROVAL OF THE HISTORICAL  AREA BOARD OF REVIEW IS REQUIRED  PRIOR TO ANY CHANGE OR MODIFICATION  OF THE REQUIREMENTS   AND/OR  CONDITIONS   SET  FORTH  IN THIS  DECISION, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED  TO:

 

 

3 a 1 Lrn s ;.pn 1 a   M ti\ o 1

28   1  lJd    12  1or  hleZ

• .I,·.~,0 1       …..   C’\  .1•.:  ‘–.~;– ._.,…U   z,: rJ“  :,!   I,”•\O -;

 

i~    11

–!                          (j                        I;

v   •.

,.!._.:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Scully

HABR#  14-09

Page 3  of  3

 

 

• ROOFING SHINGLES (IF CHANGING  COLOR)
• SIDING

o  DECORATIVE  SIDING

o  SOFFITS  & FASCIA

o GUTTERS AND LEADERS

oWINDOWS

• TRIM
• SHUTTERS
• DOORS
• LIGHTING
• LOCATION OF AIR CONDITIONING UNITS

o WALKWAYS, PATIOS

• POOLS, SPAS AND I<ENCES
• SIGNS

o   ANY  CHANGE  IN  THE  ABOVE  LIST  INCLUDING   COLOR,   MATERIAL   AND/OR MANUFACTURER

 

 

IF  YOU  HA VE  ANY  QUESTIONS,     PLEASE    CONTACT    DEBBIE   ARBO LINO, CLERK TO  THE  HISTORIC    AREA  BOARD  OF REVJKW   AT (845) 359-8410.

 

 

 

 

DECISION:    In view of the foregoing  and the testimony  before  the Board,   the application for the new front porch column  and slate  grey metal  roof by Sheffield   metals  and the new house roof in synthetic   slate with  a chipped  edge in DaVinci   Slate  Black  is  APPROVED.

 

The foregoing   resolution   was presented  and moved by Scott Wheatley,  seconded  by Joseph  Chabot;    and carried as follows:  Margaret  Raso,  aye; Larry Bucciarelli,    aye; Wayne  Garrison,    aye; William  Walther,   aye;  Scott Wheatley,   aye Thano  Schoppe},   aye; and  Joseph  Chabot,   aye.

 

The Administrative    Aide to the Board is hereby  authorized,   directed  and empowered  to sign  this decision   and file a certified   copy thereof  in the office of the Town  Cleric

 

Dated:   July 8,  2014

 

 

HISTORIC  AREAS   BOARD  OF REVIEW TOWN  OF ORANGETOWN

 

 

 

BY:~~

 

 

DISTRIBUTION:

 

APPLICANT

TOWN BOARD MEMBERS l-IABR MEMBERS SUPERVISOR

TOWN ATTORNEY

DEPUTY TOWN ATTORNEY OBZPAE

BUILDING    INSPECTOR-  B.vW.

TOWN CLERK

HIGHWAY   DEPARTMENT TOWN HISTORIAN

DEPT. OF ENVIRONMENTAL

ENGINEERING HABR, PB, FILE

PB, ZBA, ACABOR CHAIRMAN

 

 

 

 

ZS   1   lJd     12   1nr   hIOZ

 

 

 

APPROVED AS PRESENTED

 

 

TO:  Mikyong  Hyun

139 Washington  Spring Road

Palisades,  New York  10964

DECISION

 

 

 

HABR#  14-10

July 8, 2014

 

 

FROM:  HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD  OF REVIEW,  TOWN  OF ORANGETOWN

 

 

 

HABR#14-10:   Application  of  Mikyong  Hyun for review of an in-ground  pool and fence at an existing  single-family  residence.  The premises  are located  at  139 Washington Spring  Road, in the Town  of Orangetown,  Hamlet  of Palisades,  New York. Chapter  12, Section  12-4(A), Historic  Areas Board  of Review.

Tax Numbers:  78.18I2I13.1;    R-40 zoning  district.

 

 

Heard by the HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD  OF REVIEW  at a meeting  held on Tuesday, July 8, 2014 at which time the Board made the following  determination:

 

 

 

Mikyong  Hyun and Chui Hyun appeared. The following  documents  were presented:

1. Plot plan dated 4/30/ 2014.
2. Pool plan for Miki Hyun dated 6/10/ 2014 signed  and sealed by John F.

Petroccione,  P .E..

3. Picture labeled pool patio to match  existing  bluestone  patio.
4. Picture  labeled  custom  iron fence 50″ H  3 5/8″ spacing  ; color Benjamin  Moore• Iron Gate #1545.The  fence shall be self-closing,  self-latching  and with a safety bar.
5. Hydrazzo  luxurious  marble  pool finish picture.
6. Raypak  Digital pool and spa heater brochure
7. Jandy Pro Series lighting  brochure
8. Jandy Pro Series VS Flopro  variable  speed pump  brochure.

 

 

 

Mikyong  Hyun testified  that they are ready to install the lap pool at the house that they

are living in; that they are still working  to complete  the pool house and shed; that the pool shall be 14′ wide and 50′  long; that they will continue  the bluestone  patio around the pool to match the existing  bluestone  by the house;  that the existing  cottage will be used as her studio and a pool cabana;  that the east side of the property  is heavily  wooded  and the westem  side of the property  has many flowering  trees; that the pool fence will be iron

with a gate to compliment  it; that there will be two gates to get in; that there will not be

any additional  outdoor  lighting;  that the pool will have lights on the interior;  that the mechanicals  will be by the cottage  on a 4′ x 8′ patio and secluded;  and that since purchasing  the house they have planted  280 fruit and flowering  trees.

 

 

 

PUBLIC  COMMENT:

 

William  Hodash,  60 Highland  A venue;  stated that he is a neighbor  directly  across the street; and he is in support  of the application  and wanted  to see exactly  where the pool was being installed.

 

 

 

zc  1   Wd    12  1nr hlOZ

 

 

 

Hyun

HABR#  14-10

Page 2 of  3

 

 

FINDINGS OF FACT:

 

 

The Board,  after personal  observation  of the property,  hearing  all the testimony  and reviewing  same,  found as fact,  that: The application  as presented,  would not adversely  affect the Historic  District   and the surrounding  area. The design  and materials  for the proposed  pool,  patio and fence  are complimentary   to the District.

 

1. The pool shall be 14′ wide and 50′  long with  an aquavations  hyclrazzo luxurious marble pool finish in  Mediterranean   Blue.
2. 2. The patio shall be bluestone to match  the existing  bluestone  patio  by the house.
3. 3. The fence shall be custom iron fence 50″  high with 3 5/8″  spacing  color shall be

Benjamin  Moore #1545.

4. 4. There shall be interior pool  lights by Jandy Pro-Seri
5. The mechanicals  shall be by the cottage  on a 4′ x 8′ patio and secluded.

 

 

 

THIS APPROVAL/DECISION,   AND ANY MODIFICATIONS   OR CONDITIONS SET FORTH  HEREIN,  IS GRANTED BY THE HISTORICAL  AREA BOARD OF REVIEW  AND IS LIMITED   TO  THE  SPECIFIC   RELIEF   REQUESTED  AND SUBJECT  TO THE CONDITIONS  OR MODIFICATIONS,  IF ANY, SET FORTH HEREIN.

 

** PRE-1918   CONSTRUCTION:   PLEASE  BE  ADVISED:  IN  THE  HISTORIC AREA,   ALL   CONSTRUCTION   REQUIRING A  BUILDING PERMIT  OR  ANY EXTERIOR  CHANGES   (INCLUDING PAINT   COLOR)  TO  BUILDINGS CONSTRUCTED  PRIOR    TO    1918,    REQUIRES   APPROVAL   FROM    THE HISTORIC AREAS  BOARD OF REVIEW.

 

PRIOR APPROVAL OF THE HISTORICAL  AREA BOARD OF REVIEW IS REQUIRED  PRIOR TO ANY CHANGE OR MODIFICATION  OF THE REQUIREMENTS  AND/OR CONDITIONS SET FORTH IN THIS DECISION, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED  TO:

 

 

3 Cl \.:l   .:! o  s:! )131 ‘.J   N lA01

zs  l  Wd   tz  1nr  hlOZ

 

Nh\013~1f·.·~;o   .:10  W,\Ol

 

Hyun

HAER#  14-10

Page 3 of  3

 

 

o ROOFING  SHINGLES  (IF CHANGING  COLOR)

o  SIDING

D   DECORATIVE  SIDING

• SOFFITS & FASCIA
• GUTTERS AND LEADERS
• WINDOWS

oTRIM

• SHUTTERS
• DOORS “LIGHTING
• LOCATION OF AIR CONDITIONING  UNITS
• WALKWAYS, PATIOS

e POOLS, SPAS AND FENCES

o  SIGNS

• ANY CHANGE  IN  THE  ABOVE  LIST  INCLUDING   COLOR,   MATERIAL   AND/OR MANUFACTURER

 

IF  YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS,  PLEASE  CONTACT  DEBBIE  ARBOLINO, CLERK TO THE HISTORIC  AREA BOARD OF REVIBW AT (845) 359-8410.

 

 

 

 

DECISION:  In view of the foregoing  and the testimony  before  the Board,  the application for the 14′ x 50′  lap  pool,  bluestone  patio and custom  iron  fence with gate is APPROVED.

 

 

The foregoing resolution  was presented  and moved by Thano  Schoppel,  seconded  by Larry Bucciarelli;     and carried  as follows:   Margaret  Raso,  aye;  Larry Bucciarelli,   aye; Wayne  Garrison,   aye; William  Walther,   aye;  Scott Wheatley,  aye Thano  Schoppe},   aye; and  Joseph  Chabot,  aye.

 

The Administrative   Aide to the Board  is  hereby  authorized,  directed  and empowered  to sign  this  decision  and file  a certified   copy thereof  in the office of the Town  Cleric

 

Dated: July  8,  2014

 

HISTORIC  AREAS  BOARD  OF REVIEW TO         OF ORANGETOWN

 

 

 

BY:

 

Deborah  Arbolino,  Administrative    Aide

 

 

DISTRIBUTION:

 

APPLICANT

TOWN BOARD MEMBERS

l-IAI3R MEMBERS

SUPERVISOR TOWN ATTORNEY DEPUTYTOWN ATTORNEY OBZPAE

BUILDING   INSPECTOR-13.vW.

 

TOWN CLERK

HIGHWAY  DEPARTMENT

TOWN HISTORIAN

DEPT. OF ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING

HAI3R, PI3,  FILE

PB, ZBA, ACABOR CHAIRMAN

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

38U:l0   S~\H318  Nr.\01

28   T   Wd    1 z 1or   htoZ

 

Nf~\0130NV:_;O  ::iO  Ni.\01